La filosofia della religione tra nuovi atei e nuovi teisti

Translated title of the contribution: Philosophy of religion between new atheists and new theists

Paolo Diego Bubbio

    Research output: Chapter in Book / Conference PaperChapter

    Abstract

    In the essay, I first consider the recent debate between the so-called ‘new atheists’, such as Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, and Quentin Smith, and the ‘new theists’, that is, thinkers (such as William Lane Craig e Robert Koons) who welcome supernatural explanations o natural phenomena and support the ‘intelligent design theory’ or some its variations. I then argue that both the new atheists and the new theists share an approach that I call ‘meta-naturalism’. Subsequently, given that the works of the new atheists and of the new theists are usually regarded as belonging to (the discipline of) the philosophy of religion, I thereby question this assumption. I argue that only an approach to the philosophy of religion that considers the discipline as concerned with the truth of falsity of the propositional content of religious claims and notion can consider these works as belonging to (the discipline of) the philosophy of religion. I submit that, if one follows a different approach – that approach which stems from the Kantian and post-Kantian tradition of the nineteenth and twentieth century – the philosophy of religion comes to be considered as that discipline which is concerned not with the propositional content of religious claims, but only with their regulative and symbolic value. I conclude by considering the theoretical and practical benefits of the latter approach to the philosophy of religion.
    Translated title of the contributionPhilosophy of religion between new atheists and new theists
    Original languageItalian
    Title of host publicationReligione e Ontologia
    EditorsClaudio Ciancio, Maurizio Pagano
    Place of PublicationItaly
    PublisherAracne Editrice
    Pages51-58
    Number of pages8
    ISBN (Print)9788854863965
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2013

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Philosophy of religion between new atheists and new theists'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this