The present status of psychosurgery in Australia and New Zealand

Objectives: To assess the extent and nature of psychosurgery currently being performed in Australia and New Zealand, and the present status of legislation regulating its practice. Methods: Details of current legislation were obtained through inspection of statutes and direct communication with Departments of Health. All full and associate members of the Neurosurgical Society of Australasia were surveyed by postal questionnaire. Ninety-eight neurosurgeons were surveyed, of whom 72 (73%) replied. Results: In the 1980s a mean of nine (SD, 5.9) operations were performed per year; about two were performed per year in the late 1980s. Ninety per cent of these operations were performed at one centre in Sydney. The most common indications were severe and medically intractable depression and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Surgery is now exclusively stereotactic and involves the creation of lesions in the orbitomedial frontal or cingulate tracts or a combination of the two. The nature and type of surgery are comparable to those in other centres in the Western world. Regulatory legislation is in place in most, but not all, States in Australia and in New Zealand. Conclusions: Further developments of other forms of psychiatric treatments may make psychosurgery, in its present form and at its present level of validation, redundant. If it is to have a resurgence, it would have to be based on a much sounder theoretical premise, and a stronger demonstration of efficacy and predictability of effect.