In criminal investigations, bloody fingermarks located at crime scenes can provide high evidentiary value. The fingermark pattern itself and DNA profiles that may be generated from the blood can both be used for identification purposes. Given the high evidentiary value of bloody fingermarks, this evidence is often scrutinised in court. One proposition that is often raised is whether a bloody fingermark at a crime scene could be a faux bloody fingermark. Faux bloody fingermarks occur when blood is deposited over a pre-existing latent fingermark resulting in the formation of a faux bloody fingermark. When this occurs, the finger and blood have not come into direct contact with one another, putting into questions whether the person who left the fingermark was involved in the bloodshed. To address such questions in court, fingermark experts are required to report on the activity that has occurred to form the bloody fingermark. This is known as activity level reporting. To report on activity level, fingermark experts must rely on research which explains how bloody fingermarks are formed. However, research of this nature has been limited to date. This project focused on examining faux bloody fingermarks, to better understand how these fingermarks can form. Based on this research it was concluded that faux bloody fingermarks may not form every single time and certain conditions are more likely to result in a faux bloody fingermark than others. Sebaceous-rich fingermarks were most likely to generate faux bloody fingermarks compared to eccrine-rich and natural fingermarks. Blood mechanisms flow, swipe, spatter, and immersion successfully generated bloody fingermarks, whereas mechanisms drip, and pool did not. After blood has been deposited over a latent fingermark the quality does decrease in comparison to the fingermark before blood deposition. It was observed that when blood comes into contact with a sebaceous-rich fingermark, a number of factors such as gravity, blood cohesion, hydrophobic interactions and the ridge flow of the fingermark pattern can influence where the blood travels in relation to the fingermark. These interactions can assist in observing characteristics that could indicate how the bloody fingermark was formed and assist fingermark experts in explaining these observations in a court setting.
| Date of Thesis submission | 2023 |
|---|
| Original language | English |
|---|
| Awarding Institution | - Western Sydney University
|
|---|
| Supervisor | Brenden Riley (Supervisor), Robert Ebeyan (Supervisor) & Val Spikmans (Supervisor) |
|---|
Investigating the formation of faux bloody fingermarks
Rough, C. (Author). 2023
Western Sydney University thesis: Master's thesis