Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Making sense of deep ecology

  • Simon Butler

Western Sydney University thesis: Doctoral thesis

Abstract

Deep Ecology, the environmental movement first named by Arne Naess (1973), was deeply radical, criticising ‘anthropocentrism’ and, in its dominant articulation, calling for a new ‘ecocentric’ ethic of nature. Initially influential, it soon became bogged down as critics, even sympathetic ones, latched onto the apparent, and serious, paradoxes that seemed to be involved in the call that human beings develop an ethic centred on repudiating the specialness and importance of humanity in nature. This thesis argues that the critics were largely right, but that they were not right when they took this to mean abandoning the deep ecological aspiration for a nonanthropocentric awareness of nature, nor were deep ecologists wrong to think that such an awareness had deep implications for our self-understanding and our understanding of ourselves as natural beings. To make the case, the thesis: i) situates the deep ecological concern with nature in its deeper history in the modern world, beginning with the pioneering work of Lord Shaftesbury (1671-1713), and its subsequent history in German nature philosophy, Romanticism, and American Transcendentalism; ii) does this in the context of a sensitive reading of Arne Naess’ seminal articulation of ‘deep ecology’ that; iii) distinguishes its animating spirit from the moralistic reading of deep ecology that subsequently became dominant. This three-pronged strategy lets us see that the deep ecological call for a new ecologically informed understanding of nature should not be read as the call for a radically new ‘nonanthropocentric’ morality, but primarily aesthetically, in terms of the beauty and beauties of nature. The thesis articulates this understanding of deep ecology in terms of its essential naturalism and its ‘worldview’ concerns, and in a way that lets us place human moral life in nature, not set over or against it as something to be repudiated as an anthropocentric ‘prejudice.’ As such, it aims to show us that far from it being true, as the Encyclopaedia of Environmental Ethics and Philosophy has it, ‘that Deep Ecology has reached its logical conclusion and has exhausted itself’, it is a logically secure movement with a deep and rich history in philosophy and the ecological sciences, and while there may be maybe ongoing and open debates surrounding many of its primary concerns, these are no insurmountable obstacles to its overall aims.
Date of Thesis submission2023
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • Western Sydney University
SupervisorJohn Hadley (Supervisor)

Cite this

'