Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

The experience of girls in detention under the juvenile justice system of Bangladesh

  • Shilpi Dey

Western Sydney University thesis: Doctoral thesis

Abstract

This study aims to explore the experiences of adolescent girls detained under the JJS in Bangladesh. It focuses on to what extent their rights are observed and protected under the JJS and explores whether girls are subjected to abuse before, during or after detention. This research applied a qualitative approach where in-depth interviews and focus group discussion (FGD) were applied to collect data from three groups of participants: current inmates, ex- inmates and juvenile justice professionals (JJPs) at the Girls’ Development Centre (GDC). This research has found the following outcome. First, it was found that many girls already had a history of abuse before coming under the control of the JJS, in addition to being treated harshly in the system, where they are subjected to abuse by the staff and their peers. Second in many cases their coping strategies to escape abuse were criminalized through detention alongside alleged offenders at the same Centre. Third, detention has been used as a first resort rather than last for both categories of girls: victims and offenders, instead of offering alternative care (e.g., OOHC) for the first category, and diversion (e.g., probation, bail) for the latter. Fourth, they hardly receive separate treatment to adult offenders or/and alleged offenders, particularly under the care of the GDC. Fifth, girls are not given all their rights (e.g., separate treatment, freedom and liberty and others). Sixth, many girls felt the Centre is a “jail”, or “prison” where they are “caged” like a “bird” and “tarred by the same brush” without having done any offences. Seventh, the girls reproduce gender violence and police each other while detained under the care of the Centre, which is a concerning issue for their right to safety and protection. Eighth, the offered services and programme are minimal and hardly meet their needs. In addition, they are not trauma-informed and gender-responsive, to address the specific issues experienced by the girls. The thesis proposes to bring policy and practice changes to the JJS, to ensure the wellbeing and best interests of justice-involved girls, as victims of crime, and/or as alleged offender.
Date of Thesis submission2023
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • Western Sydney University
SupervisorBrian Stout (Supervisor), Ana Rodas (Supervisor) & Rimple Mehta (Supervisor)

Cite this

'